Overview Methodology PE Paradox BVB Hertha BSC
Akte Bundesliga › Soccer Economics
Soccer Economics

Bundesliga Financial X-Ray

Equity research methodology applied to football clubs — systematic balance sheet analysis, adjusted asset valuations and predictive risk scores

BETA Soccer Economics is under construction. First analyses: BVB and Hertha BSC. More clubs to follow.

Soccer Economics bridges historical analysis with the intelligence world. We analyze Bundesliga balance sheets using the methodology equity research analysts apply to listed companies — except we correct the systematic distortions in football accounting.

The core thesis: Published club accounts contain systematic distortions. Stadiums are valued at book cost rather than earning power. Free-transfer players appear at book value zero despite being worth 150 million. Off-balance-sheet obligations like long-term leases and transfer installments are missing entirely. The Financial X-Ray corrects these distortions.

Nothing like this exists. Swiss Ramble is descriptive, Deloitte Money League is rankings. Nobody builds a predictive model from the balance sheets. We do.

Financial X-Ray — Pilot Analyses

Borussia Dortmund Publicly listed AG — transparency, Signal Iduna Park as leverage risk Financial X-Ray → Hertha BSC Crisis mode — Windhorst/777 disaster, second division TV cliff, Olympic Stadium = rent Financial X-Ray →

Financial Stability Ranking — All 21 Clubs

#ClubScoreClassRevenuePC RatioSquad Value
1 FC Bayern Munich
1. Bundesliga		 88 Antifragile €900M 53% €920M
2 Bayer 04 Leverkusen
1. Bundesliga		 82 Antifragile €400M 48% €580M
3 RB Leipzig
1. Bundesliga		 78 Antifragile €370M 45% €480M
4 VfL Wolfsburg
1. Bundesliga		 75 Robust €220M 50% €200M
5 SC Freiburg
1. Bundesliga		 75 Robust €150M 42% €170M
6 TSG 1899 Hoffenheim
1. Bundesliga		 72 Robust €200M 47% €220M
7 Eintracht Frankfurt
1. Bundesliga		 68 Robust €280M 50% €320M
8 Borussia Dortmund
1. Bundesliga		 62 Robust €480M 58% €520M
9 VfB Stuttgart
1. Bundesliga		 62 Robust €220M 50% €300M
10 1. FC Union Berlin
1. Bundesliga		 60 Robust €120M 48% €110M
11 Borussia Mönchengladbach
1. Bundesliga		 58 Robust €175M 55% €140M
12 FSV Mainz 05
1. Bundesliga		 55 Robust €120M 50% €130M
13 FC Augsburg
1. Bundesliga		 52 Robust €105M 52% €90M
14 FC St. Pauli
1. Bundesliga		 50 Robust €80M 48% €55M
15 SV Werder Bremen
1. Bundesliga		 48 Fragile €130M 54% €110M
16 SC Paderborn 07
2. Bundesliga		 38 Fragile €30M 50% €15M
17 Fortuna Düsseldorf
2. Bundesliga		 35 Fragile €55M 52% €25M
18 1. FC Köln
2. Bundesliga		 32 Fragile €95M 56% €45M
19 Hamburger SV
2. Bundesliga		 30 Fragile €100M 55% €40M
20 FC Schalke 04
2. Bundesliga		 28 Fragile €85M 52% €35M
21 Hertha BSC
2. Bundesliga		 18 Fragile €75M 62% €30M

5 Modules per Club

Module 1

Club P&L

Revenue breakdown, EBITDA, net margin, 3-year trend with CAGR and benchmark against league average.

Module 2

Adjusted Balance Sheet

Stadium earning value, squad NAV, phantom asset elimination, off-balance-sheet obligations.

Module 3

DFL Compliance

Equity ratio, liquidity proof, debt service capacity. Distance to Default.

Module 4

Transfer Firepower

Net transfer budget without DFL ratio violation. Directly usable for prediction markets.

Module 5

Structural Risk Score

5 dimensions → Fragile / Robust / Antifragile classification.

Methodology → The PE Paradox →

Frequently Asked Questions

What is a Financial X-Ray?
A systematic balance sheet analysis of a football club using equity research methodology — with adjusted asset valuations, DFL compliance checks, and a predictive risk score.
What is the Structural Risk Score?
A score based on 5 dimensions: stadium exposure, wage rigidity, TV revenue dependency, investor concentration, and equity buffer. Outcome: Fragile, Robust, or Antifragile.